CHAIRMAN´S REPORT
During
the past year, two more Ordovician GSSPs (Diabasbrottet and
Fågelsång) were ratified by the IUGS, and the Green Point GSSP for
the Cambrian/Ordovician boundary was dedicated on 1 June 2001. Only two GSSPs remain to be selected to
complete the global time scale for the Ordovician System. Three meetings wholly or in part
dedicated to Ordovician geology/paleontology were held in 2001, and future
meetings of importance include the International Palaeontological Congress in
July 2002, the 9th International Symposium on the Ordovician System in August
2003, and the 32rd International Geological Congress in August 2004. With its mandate from IUGS to complete
selection of GSSPs for all Phanerozoic stages by 2008, the voting membership of
the International Commission on Stratigraphy meets in June 2002 in Urbino, Italy with
the goals of addressing the challenge from IUGS and developing a new mission
and organization for ICS. Pertinent
to these discussions is the future mission of the Subcommission on Ordovician
Stratigraphy. With the unfortunate
passing this year of Mikhail Apollonov, a long-time voting (titular) member of
the Ordovician Subcommission, Andrei Dronov (St.
Petersburg, Russia) was
selected as a new voting member. It
is likely that several voting members will retire in 2004, requiring additional
new members to lead the Ordovician Subcommission into the future.
Progress on GSSPs
The Fågelsång GSSP was
the subject of a ballot by the Subcommission held in September-October
2001. In this ballot, “The Global boundary Stratotype Section
and Point (GSSP) for the base of the Upper Ordovician Series is defined 1.4 m
below a phosphorite marker bed in the E14a outcrop along the south bank of the
Sularp Brook at Fågelsång, 8 km east of the center of the City of Lund, Scania, southern Sweden. This level coincides with the first
appearance of the graptolite Nemagraptus
gracilis.” This GSSP also serves as the lower boundary of
the yet-to-be-named lower stage of the Upper Ordovician Series and the upper
boundary of the Darriwilian Stage. The GSSP proposal is published in
Bergström et al., (2000; Episodes,
v. 23, no. 3, p. 102-109).
Results of the ballot are as follows:
F.G. Aceñolaza (Argentina) Yes
G.L. Albanesi
(Argentina) Yes
C.R. Barnes (Canada) Yes
S.M. Bergström (USA) Yes
D.L. Bruton (Norway) Yes
Chen Xu (China) Yes
R.A. Cooper (New Zealand) Yes
O. Fatka (Czech Republic) Yes
S.C. Finney (USA) Yes
R.A. Fortey (UK) Abstain
J.C. Gutiérrez-Marco (Spain) Yes
W. Huff (USA) Yes
C.E. Mitchell (USA) Yes
R. Nicoll (Australia) Yes
A. Owen (UK) Yes
F. Paris (France) Abstain
L. Popov (Russia) Yes
Wang Xiaofeng (China) Yes
S.H. Williams (Canada) Yes
Zhou Zhiyi (China) Yes
With 18 yes votes, 0 no votes, and 2
abstain votes, the GSSP was approved by the Subcommission with a 100%
majority. Subsequently, the
Diabasbrottet GSSP, approved last year by the Subcommission, and the Fågelsång
GSSP were approved by the International Commission on Stratigraphy by 87%
majority votes and then ratified by the IUGS Executive. Kent Larrson and colleagues at Lund University are planning dedication ceremonies
for the Diabasbrottet and Fågelsång GSSPs for the Spring 2003. I
encourage Ordovician specialists, especially those in the Baltic region, to
attend.
Dedication
of the Green Point GSSP for the base of the Ordovician System was held on 1
June 2001
with an outstanding ceremony organized by Henry Williams, Godfrey Nowlan and
colleagues in Newfoundland.
Those in attendance included a good sampling of Ordovician
stratigraphers/ paleontologists,
representatives of the Newfoundland government, officials and many
employees of Parks Canada, local geologists, and a number of local
residents. Following comments by
government officials, Godfrey Nowlan, and myself, an
impressive plaque was unveiled.
This was followed by the “graptolite rap” performed by Fred
Sheppard (Parks Canada) and substantial food and drink at the interpretive
center of the Gros Morne National Park. Photographs and a report on the
dedication ceremony were published on the front page of the Corner Brook newspaper the following
morning.
Of
particular note, the Subcommission on Silurian Stratigraphy has voted to
re-evaluate and reconsider the Dobs Linn GSSP for the base of the Silurian
System, which sets the upper limit of the Ordovician System. For detailed information, I direct you
to Silurian Times No. 9 at
http://www.stfx.ca/people /mmelchin/SILURIAN9.HTM.
As
reported last year, selection of the GSSP for the base of the Middle Ordovician
Series is critical for completion of the global time scale for the Ordovician
System. Following a field excursion
in November 2000 and subsequent study of graptolites collected at that time,
serious concerns were raised with regard to the FAD of the conodont Tripodus laevis in the Whiterock Narrows section, Nevada - the primary candidate biohorizon
and stratotype section under consideration by the Subcommission. The issues were discussed further at a
Subcommission meeting in November 2001 at the Annual Meeting of the Geological
Society of America in Boston, and much of the essence of these discussions are
in articles and documents posted on the web site
(http://seis.natsci.csulb.edu/ordstrat1/ default.htm) for the Ordovician
Stratigraphy Discussion Forum.
Accordingly, the Subcommission encouraged further work on sections in
the Great
Basin that
might serve as a Global Stratotype section and a call was sent to all
corresponding members of the Subcommission to consider and to submit proposals
for alternative biohorizons and stratotype sections for the boundary. At this time, Guillermo Albanesi has
proposed a GSSP in Argentina, Ray Ethington is investigating the
conodont succession at sections in the Ibex area, Utah, and Chuck Mitchell and Svend
Stouge will be evaluating western Newfoundland sections during the summer. Those wishing to join in the discussions
are encouraged to post articles directly on the Ordovician Stratigraphy web
site. Extensive documents,
including proposals for biohorizons and/or candidate stratotype sections,
should be sent to me, and I will arranged for them to
be loaded on the web site.
Stig
Bergström is leader of a group that is evaluating biohorizons and sections
for the GSSP for the base of the upper stage of the Upper Ordovician
Series. All who wish to participate
in this working group should contact Stig.
Both
boundaries will be a primary focus of Subcommission business meetings and
discussion sessions at the 9th International Symposium on the Ordovician
System. Those working on potential
GSSPs will be expected to present proposals. It is my goal to move towards completion
of the Ordovician time scale by 2004.
The Future of ICS and
the Ordovician Subcommission
Through my service as 2nd Vice-Chair
of the International Commission on Stratigraphy, I’ve developed an
appreciation of the many activities and accomplishments of the ICS and its many
Subcommissions, as well as its present challenges. The IUGS has mandated that the ICS
complete selection of GSSPs for all Phanerozoic stages by 2008. And, what is the future of ICS after
2008? The present executive
committee, led by its dynamic chair Felix Gradstein, is especially active and
taking steps to address these challenges.
Accordingly, the “First Conference on Future Directions in
Stratigraphy” will take place in Urbino, Italy, 14-16 June 2002. I have the pleasure of serving as
organizing chair. Besides the full
executive committee, almost all ICS Subcommissions will be represented. This will be the first such meeting of
full voting membership of ICS in many years. Its importance is recognized by the IUGS
through the attendance of Werner Janoshek, Secretary General (and former
Treasurer) of IUGS, and Attilio Boriani, President of the 32nd International
Geological Congress (and former Secretary General of IUGS). Issues to be addressed include: 1)
strategies to ensure progress within Subcommissions, 2) a new mission for ICS,
3) a new organizational structure, 4) association status and new sources of
funding, 5) dissemination of knowledge, results, and products, 6) a
stratigraphic prize, and 7) plans for the 32nd IGC. Draft resolutions will be formulated and
will be the focus of discussions at the 32nd IGC that will be open to the
entire ICS membership. Chair
Gradstein has proposed that high-resolution global change as recorded in
dynamic stratigraphy, i.e. geological process oriented stratigraphy, would be
an exciting and socially responsible challenge. No doubt, other missions will be proposed
and discussed. I encourage you to
visit the web site for the International Commission on Stratigraphy
(http://www.micropress.org/stratigraphy/).
Among its varied contents are the Global Time Scale with approved GSSPs,
the abridged version of the International Stratigraphic Guide, and descriptions
and photographs of the many of the ratified GSSPs.
Consistent
with a new mission for ICS is a new mission for the Ordovician
Subcommission. It is my opinion
that the GOES (Global Ordovician Earth System) program could be that
mission. Its goal is to encourage
integrated multi-disciplinary investigations of global events during the
Ordovician Period. Ricardo Astini,
Chris Barnes, and Bill Berry were asked to serve as a steering committee for
this informal program with the Late Ordovician mass extinction and associated
global changes being an initial issue to be addressed. But, many more issues can be formulated. The Subcommission will sponsor a
symposium session with the title Global Ordovician Earth System at the 32nd
IGC. It will include papers on the
Late Ordovician event, but other topics are encouraged. Should you wish to participate, please
contact the session conveners: myself, Chris Barnes,
and Bill Berry. The GOES program
also will be a topic for serious consideration at the 9th ISOS not only through
presentations in the technical program, but also in discussions of the future
status and mission of the Ordovician Subcommission.
Other
Activities/Future Meetings
Although
I was not able to participate, there were several successful meetings last
year: the WOGOGOB meeting in May 2001, organized by Svend Stouge and colleagues
in Copenhagen, which included a field excursion to Fågelsång; the
meeting “Early Palaeozoic Palaeogeography and Palaeobiogeography of
Western Europe and North Africa” organized by Tom Servais and colleagues
in Lille, France, a product of which will be a book of the same title with
contributions on the Ordovician; a meeting for IGCP 410 at Riverside,
California hosted by Mary Droser and resulting in an important publication on
Ordovician Biodiversity, and an field excursion to Mongolia organized by IGCP
410 (participants tell me that, although physically and mentally demanding, it
was an awesome experience).
Many
of you may receive this newsletter after returning from the International
Palaeontological Congress in Sydney. The Ordovician System will compose a
substantial part of the technical program with a final meeting of IGCP 410 and
Ordovician graptolites will be the major focus of a field excursion to Victoria.
Organization
for the 9th ISOS in San Juan, Argentina in August 2003 is far advanced; the
2nd circular is included in this newsletter. From some, I have heard concerns that the
economic crisis in Argentina will impact the meeting. Our Argentine colleagues are suffering,
but I assure you that the meeting is very well organized and will be a
logistical success. I encourage all
of you to attend. The meeting will
be run jointing with a Field Meeting of the Subcommission on Silurian
Stratigraphy and with an International Conference on Graptolites, ensuring a
large number of interested participants.
The field excursions provide the opportunity to examine richly
fossiliferous successions of both Gondwanan and Laurentian character. And, there are serious issues to be
addressed, in particular, the remaining GSSPs, and the future mission,
direction, and organization of the Subcommission.
The
32nd International Geological Congress scheduled for August 2004 in Florence provides not only a remarkable
setting but also an opportunity for business important to the future of the
Subcommission. It will be a time at
which a new chair and new voting (titular) members of the Subcommission begin
their terms. The GOES program will be on the technical program. An important
open meeting will be held on the future of the International Commission on
Stratigraphy; similar discussions will take place with regard to the Ordovician
Subcommission.
Stan Finney